High intensity interval training (HIIT) gets results - fact. However what do we mean by HIIT? The different permutations are endless: 15 second intervals through to 5 minute intervals; short recovery, one to one or full recovery; flat out intensity or a fixed percentage of max effort.
Mix these factors together and it becomes clear the high intensity training actually covers a wide range of possible workouts. A group of antipodean researchers set out to investigate whether the length of the rest interval was a crucial factor in the success of an interval session.
12 physically active female participants were recruited for the study and asked to complete 5 weeks of interval training consisting of between 6 and 10 two minute intervals, performed 3 times a week.
The crucial difference was that half of the ladies were given 3 minutes rest after each interval (HIT-3) with the other half only given one minute (HIT-1). Before and after the training program, standard lab fitness measures were taken, plus a repeated sprint test following a high intensity endurance trial.
Muscle biopsies and other physiological measures were taken to try and evaluate the effect of each test and training session.
In a nutshell
From a practical perspective, the main result from shortening the rest interval is to make it much ‘harder' (You could try the sessions yourself, although it is intuitively obvious!).
At the end of the workouts with only 1 minute recovery, the build up of metabolites such as blood and muscle lactate was considerably higher, heart rate was higher and PCr (a key energy store) was reduced. The hypothesis was that the extra metabolic disturbance should lead to a greater training stimulus and a more pronounced adaptation.
However, despite improvements in performance for both HIT-3 and HIT-1 groups, there was no difference between groups. In other words the extra ‘stress' with only one minute recovery did not lead to a bigger improvement.
From a scientific perspective, some of the data on the physiological effect of the training protocol is interesting but the study does not go far enough to give satisfactory practical info on choosing the length of your rest interval.
The research paper ends with speculation that no difference between groups was found because both training programs were sufficiently ‘hard' to trigger fitness adaptations in a group who were admittedly not trained cyclists.
Training is about searching for the minimum effective dose - if 3 minute rests make the session easier and still gets results, then why make things more challenging than they need be? The second important principle here is progression.
Why not start with longer rest intervals and retain the option of reducing the rest interval once you stop improving? In reality there is no optimum length of rest interval, it will depend on the goal of the session and your individual requirements. More work is needed to understand the factors that affect this decision though.
CW Awards: Last chance to nominate those who have helped and inspired in 2021
Nominations for our three reader-based categories will close this Friday. Nominate now and be part of our 2021 celebrations.
By Simon Richardson •
'I thought I was having a heart attack on the start line': Mechanical engineer, mother of two, making Pakistani history
Alongside Asma Jan, Kanza Malik made history as the first Pakistani women to race internationally
By Jonny Long •
The life of a Paralympics tandem pilot
Tandem pilot Helen Scott discusses her experiences on route to silver and bronze medal with Aileen McGlynn at the Paralympic Games in London.
By Richard Windsor •
Cycling knee pain: everything you need to know
Knee pain is common among cyclists - we explain some of the causes and how to address them with help from a coach, bike fitter and osteopath.
By Michelle Arthurs-Brennan •
Lower back pain: causes and prevention for cyclists
Correct bike geometry and set-up are both vital for a healthy back, but for some cyclists, fatigue produces undesirable changes in muscle movement which also affects spinal posture
By Michelle Arthurs-Brennan •
Train your body to beat the heat
How the pros train their bodies to cope with the heat, and why it's easier to do it than you might think.
By Cycling Weekly •
Climb like a Grand Tour stage winner
How to climb faster without losing weight? Chris Marshall-Bell asks all-star selection of WorldTour stage winners
By Chris Marshall-Bell •
How to be aero (without breaking UCI rules)
Cycling’s governing body has banned the forearms TT position on road bikes, so what is the next fastest position?
By Alex Ballinger •
How cross-training can help reach your cycling goals
Got a big challenge lined up for later in the summer?
By Paul Knott •
You ARE a real cyclist: Taking on impostor syndrome
In a sport hung up on rules and details, it’s easy to feel you’re falling short of the mark and failing to fit in. Dr Josephine Perry goes to work on impostor syndrome
By Josephine Perry •