To change bike or not change bike? The question of the day at the Tour de France time trial
Some stuck on their time trial bike throughout stage 16's hilly course - like Jonas Vingegaard, who won - while others opted to change
Road bike or TT machine? That proved to be one of the main questions before the Tour de France's stage 16 time trial to Combloux - a hilly one - and one of the main discussion points afterwards.
It wasn’t so much about what sort of machine to start with – more which machine to finish with – with the steep final climb of the Côte de Domancy in mind.
From sports science to simply ‘didn’t feel like it’, riders and teams offered up a variety of takes on the issue, and there were a healthy number of both types at the finish.
The day’s winner Jonas Vingegaard (Jumbo-Visma) came down on the side of the specialist machine, staying on his bike from start to finish as, in fact, did all his team-mates.
Among those to make the swap included his nemesis Tadej Pogačar (UAE Team Emirates), and time trialling specialist Stefan Küng (Groupama-FDJ), who swapped to a road bike for the Domancy and proclaimed it “definitely the right option”, at least for him.
“Maybe some guys that are going for the win will stay on the TT bike,” he said with keen predictive skills, “but for me it was definitely the right choice.
“In the end the Côte de Domancy is really really steep, time trial bikes are made to go fast, not uphill quite slowly. It’s not just about the weight it’s also about the position on the bike, so yeah, that’s why I did the bike change.”
Get The Leadout Newsletter
The latest race content, interviews, features, reviews and expert buying guides, direct to your inbox!
Giulio Ciccone, for whom the Domancy was key in his battle to retain the polka dot jersey, also came down on the side of the road bike. “I did a normal tempo just to keep going and then we changed the bike 1.5km from the climb,” said the Lidl-Trek man. “It was just full gas from the bottom, I went just with my legs and my feelings,” he added, referencing the fact that his radio had stopped working.
The bike change (and indeed his legs) seemed to do the trick though, for he put 40 seconds into his big King of the Mountains rival Neilson Powless, bolstering his lead to a still-scant five points.
Simon Yates, on the other hand, put forward an alternative thesis on the thorny issue: “I couldn’t be bothered,” he said. Tongue not entirely out of cheek perhaps, though he equally pointed out: “I’m not in a position where I think I would win and it just complicates things a bit.
"Our sports scientist [Marco] Pinotti also told me it was faster to change,” he admitted, “but I wasn’t in a position to mess around."
Looking at the results, will Yates wonder what may have been? He wouldn’t have won but eight extra seconds would have seen him skip ahead of Pello Bilbao and Wout van Aert to finish third.
UAE Team Emirates team principal Mauro Gianetti defended Tadej Pogačar’s bike change. That was certainly not why he lost, he said: “We did all the tests and everything, and for us it was an advantage to change the bike for Tadej, and not change the bike for Adam Yates for example.
“It is individual, and this was clear from the beginning,” he added. “We lost 10 seconds in the change of the bike, that we knew, but we had 1-30 lost in the end, so it was not the change of the bike that decided it.
Jumbo-Visma DS Arthur Van Dongen, who was surely relieved to see that ultimately, his team's plan prevailed, said: "We made some calculations and in our opinion it made no sense and I think the calculations were right.
Of Pogačar he added: "I think he was behind before the bike change a lot … it's up to them – everyone has their own plan, their decision and goals."
Thank you for reading 20 articles this month* Join now for unlimited access
Enjoy your first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription
Join now for unlimited access
Try first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
After cutting his teeth on local and national newspapers, James began at Cycling Weekly as a sub-editor in 2000 when the current office was literally all fields.
Eventually becoming chief sub-editor, in 2016 he switched to the job of full-time writer, and covers news, racing and features.
A lifelong cyclist and cycling fan, James's racing days (and most of his fitness) are now behind him. But he still rides regularly, both on the road and on the gravelly stuff.
-
Red Bull-Bora Hansgrohe – the new name in the Tour de France peloton this July
New name, new jerseys, new budget, as German team aims to create the next cycling icon from within
By James Shrubsall Published
-
'In three weeks there can be a lot of surprises' - Tadej Pogačar says no room for complacency ahead of Giro d'Italia debut
Slovenian labelled the favourite for overall victory in Rome, but expecting a big challenge from Romain Bardet and Geraint Thomas
By Tom Thewlis Published
-
From 'best condition ever' to 'worst' - Wout van Aert reflects on crashing out of Classics
Visma-Lease a Bike rider rues his misfortune in team documentary after Spring campaign wiped out by crash
By Tom Thewlis Published
-
Tour de France stage winner leaves hospital, one month after being hit by car driver
Lennard Kämna to fly home to Germany to begin rehabilitation after incident in Tenerife last month
By Tom Thewlis Published
-
Wout van Aert back on drop bars as he says he’s 'almost professional again' in Strava post
Visma-Lease a Bike rider broke his collarbone, sternum and several ribs in a high speed crash at Dwars door Vlaanderen
By Tom Thewlis Published
-
Jonas Vingegaard leaves hospital after Itzulia Basque Country horror crash
Danish rider underwent surgery to repair broken collarbone; too early to know whether Tour de France return will be possible
By Tom Thewlis Published
-
Will the Tour de France be won by the last man standing?
With Jonas Vingegaard, Remco Evenepoel and Primož Roglič hitting the deck at Itzulia Basque Country, all three now face battle to get their seasons back on track
By Adam Becket Published
-
Tom Pidcock unable to bear weight on right leg after Itzulia Basque Country crash
British rider crashed during recon of opening stage time trial last weekend and injured his right hip
By Tom Thewlis Published
-
Mark Cavendish to miss Scheldeprijs as illness continues to affect schedule
Cavendish will ride Presidential Cycling Tour of Türkiye later this month, Astana Qazaqstan confirms
By Tom Thewlis Published
-
Mathieu van der Poel not intimidated by Tadej Pogačar’s form ahead of Milan-San Remo clash
Dutchman starts his 2024 road season at Italian Monument on Saturday
By Tom Thewlis Published