Mark Cavendish found himself at the centre of controversy again after today’s sprint at the Tour de France in Bourg-lès-Valence. Cavendish convincingly won ahead of Italian Alessandro Petacchi, but his win came after his HTC-Columbia lead-out man Mark Renshaw head-butted a rival.

The race jury disqualified Renshaw after it reviewed the replay.

“I am really disappointed with the decisions. The commissaries make their decisions and we think there were different circumstances,” Cavendish responded to the decision. “Mark is a great rider and a incredibly good bike handler.”

The decision overshadowed Cavendish’s third victory in this year’s Tour de France and created more controversy around an already controversial season.

He criticised his teammate André Greipel in April, gave a two-fingered salute in the Tour of Romandy in May and treated his bike roughly last week after losing. This time, though, he did not directly start the controversy.

Renshaw explained that “it was track tactics” he used.

In the final metres, the Australian fought for space with Garmin-Transitions’ Julian Dean. He leaned his head into Dean’s upper body to make way for himself and to allow Cavendish to get through.

Cavendish easily won the sprint, Petacchi was second and Dean’s captain, Tyler Farrar, finished third.

“It’s not normal, you have to ride a straight line,” said Farrar. “He let ‘Cav’ by, and then he tries to crash everyone against the barriers. You have to think of the safety of everyone.”

After a left turn, the final kilometre of the 184.5-kilometre stage started. It was a dead-straight finish where HTC-Columbia led with Bernhard Eisel and then Renshaw.

“I saw Julian on the right, he had his left elbow out over Mark’s right elbow, to stop him from moving forward,” explained Cavendish. “That leaves the situation where they can tangle bars and they can come down. Mark did a great job of giving himself and the rest of the guys space. It was the only way of keeping Julian’s elbow away.”

Cavendish started his sprint from farther out than normal, near 375 metres, and said that he was happy he could pull it off. His happiness turned to frustration, though, as storm of controversy again came down on him.

His next chance for a sprint win comes next Friday in Bordeaux. Missing Adam Hansen due to an early crash and now Renshaw, he will have more difficulty pulling off a win to erase this controversy.

“We will see what we can do with the situation.”

Tour de France 2010: Latest news

Did Armstrong own a stake in Tailwind Sports, or not?

Cavendish in a ‘must win’ situation for Tour’s green jersey

Millar rides through pain barrier to make time cut

Roche alongside Tour’s top men ahead of Pyrenees

Wiggins to aim for Tour de France stage win?

Dan Lloyd battles on in Tour despite groin strain

Bradley Wiggins: Tour rest day conference

Evans faces rough ride in yellow

Riis secures replacement sponsor but Shleck in doubt

Tour de France 2010: rest day review (July 12)

Armstrong’s Tour de France dream ends

Sky’s objective clear ahead of Tour’s high mountains

The Feed Zone (July 10): Tour de France news and views


Tour de France 2010: Stage reports

Stage 10: Cavendish bags third stage win but his lead-out man is kicked out of race

Stage 10: Paulinho claims narrow stage victory on Bastille day

Stage nine: Casar wins stage as Schleck and Contador go head-to-head

Stage seven: Chavanel wins stage and takes overall as Thomas drops out of Tour’s white

Stage six: Cavendish makes it two as Tour hots up

Stage five: Cavendish wins his first stage of Tour

Stage four: Petacchi wins into Reims

Stage three: Hushovd takes dramatic win; Thomas second on stage and GC

Stage three live coverage: As it happened

Stage two: Comeback man Chavanel takes victory in Spa

Stage one: Petacchi wins in Brussels as bunch left in tatters

Prologue: Cancellara pips Martin to win

Tour de France 2010: Photos

Stage 10 photo gallery

Stage nine photo gallery

Stage eight photo gallery

Tour 2010 wallpaper

Stage seven photo gallery

Stage six photo gallery

Stage five photo gallery

Stage four photo gallery

Stage three photo gallery

Stage two photo gallery

Stage one gallery

Prologue photo gallery

Tour de France 2010: Videos

Stage 10 video highlights

Stage nine video highlights

Stage eight video highlights

Stage seven video highlights

Stage six video highlights

Stage five video highlights

Stage four video highlights

Stage three video highlights

Stage two video highlights

Stage one video highlights

Prologue video highlights

Tour de France 2010: Race guide

Tour de France 2010: Cycling Weekly’s coverage index

Official start list, with race numbers

Brits at the Tour 2010

Tout team guide

Tour jerseys: What they are and what they mean

Brits in the Tours: From Robinson to Wiggins

Tour de France 2010: Pictures

Tour team presentation, Rotterdam

Tour teams take to the cobbles: Photo special


  • Elton

    This was entirely Dean’s fault. Like Cav says: “I saw Julian on the right, he had his left elbow out over Mark’s right elbow, to stop him from moving forward,” explained Cavendish. “That leaves the situation where they can tangle bars and they can come down. Mark did a great job of giving himself and the rest of the guys space. It was the only way of keeping Julian’s elbow away.”
    The race footage clearly shows how he was trying to block Renshaw with his elbow and could have caused a crash right on the barriers; do we hear that Dean was reprimanded for HIS actions. No. Dave’s right, he should be fined. Instead Cav’s main man gets kicked out for just trying to defend his line and get Cav the win, which thankfully he still got. Again, one of the best teams is penalised, just like Cav was last year for ‘forcing’ Thor into the barriers, even though again, it’s clear that Cav NEVER changed his line, the barriers came into the road. Like Katie said, sour bloody grapes for the French….

  • Mike Primavesi

    As usual, the Anglophobic French cheat.

  • Dave Morley

    The overhead helicopter footage shows what happened. Julian Dean was the cause of the problem, Mark Renshaw, rightly, reacted and there can be no complain other than Dean getting away with his blocking attempt without penalty. The second incident, of Renshaw deviating from his line to hinder Tyler Farrar sprint is more problematical. I suspect that Renshaw was still het up about the dean incident, but he should be penalised for this; but not thrown out of the race. Renshaw should be fined, but reinstated and allowed to continue in the race. Dean should also be fined.

  • katie

    Dean started it as CAV said not once but twice French TV played it over time after time, Renshaw did no more than the McEwan did a couple of years back. If it was so dangerous why did none of the sprinters back off, if you notice CAV stayed on the wheel.

    Sour grapes and inexperienced judges again but then this kind of reaction is a French thing and yes I live in France