Should you be riding U-shaped deep section rims?

With the changing shape of aerodynamic rims, Stuart Clapp examines if the shift to wider wheels spells the end for the old-school

His findings are why modern designs are incorporating broader rims, making wind-cheating wheels as ubiquitous on the club run as in the pro peloton.

>>> Are wider tyres really faster?

There are many factors, such as weight, stiffness, aerodynamics and stability, at play here and it’s the blend of all of those different attributes that constitute the best rim. Opting for wider tyres makes sense, especially on pitted UK roads, so to keep the aerodynamics, a wide U-shaped rim is the only answer.

Zipp

Zipp have made the switch

“In terms of aerodynamics, the difference between V-shaped and these wider designs is minimal. For Lightweight, there’s good reason why we haven’t switched. It’s because our wheels aren’t just the lightest, but also the stiffest, and power transfer in a race scenario is one of the most important parts of our wheel design. This rim profile helps find that balance between those opposing forces.”

Find the best aero wheels for you 

>>> Buyer’s guide to road bike tyres (video)

>>> It’s never too late: taking up racing as a veteran

"Typically, when you reduce the side force, you increase aero drag. We’ve been able to maintain the same aero drag while reducing the side force.”

Our take

Lightweight Fernweg wheels

Lightweight are sticking with V-shaped rims

When aero wheels first adorned the bikes of professionals, and rich amateurs, they were not the same shape as they are today. Round, yes, but the similarity ended there.

>>> Disc brakes in the WorldTour: are they necessary on road bikes?

Similarities can be drawn from the Zipp wheels to other fresh aero rims, such as the Orbis II rims from 3T and the new range from Reynolds. The wider rim track creates a smoother interaction

between tyre and wheel, giving more room to run wider tyres for reduced rolling resistance.

Refined, tweaked and bettered to perform more effectively against the laws of physics, it’s easier to remain in control on deep rims now, but why are there still companies, including Lightweight, still using the flat sided ‘V’ design?

The late — and great — Steve Hed pioneered modern aero wheels. He was the first to look beyond the leading edge of the wheel and realised it is the trailing edge that causes around 40 per cent of the drag and most of the instability.

Along with Steve Hed’s company, HED, brands such as Zipp have also been at the forefront of wheel design. It could be argued its latest U-shaped rim, seen on its dimpled, crosswind defying Firecrest range, has helped reinforce the change.

Wider rims, less resistance

>>> Will wider rims make you faster?

“We eventually discovered that when the rim is slightly wider than the tyre, the frontal area is only slightly bigger, but it offers huge benefits in terms of lateral resistance, so bike handling and stability in crosswind are improved.”

Then there’s the improved stability, which makes them more compliant. Evidence suggests that old school V-shaped aero rims will be out the back of the peloton completely before long, perhaps as a result of a hefty crosswind.

Which wheels should you buy? 

>>> Mavic wheels go U-shaped in the pro peloton

Yes: Jason Fowler, product manager, Zipp Wheels

Paul Lew, technology founder at Reynolds, recently reviewed wind tunnel data he’d collected in 1989 and compared it to wheels produced and tested in 2014. The aerodynamic drag was surprisingly similar. The reason is in the rubber.

Back in those early days, 18/19mm tyres were a popular choice. The rim width was narrower too, around 20mm. So comparatively a modern 25mm tyre on a 26mm rim has similar numbers in the wind tunnel. It’s in a crosswind where modern rims prevail.

Maxime Brunand, Mavic’s road product manager, says: “V-shaped was the go-to design for the first deep-dish rims. Everyone was focusing on lowering the frontal drag, but as we accumulated

data from wind tunnel sessions, the parameters were challenged.

The material they were made from has changed from alloy to carbon, and along with it, their weight penalty has all but disappeared. In those early years, time triallists ran the risk of being blown into a neighbouring field at the faintest sneeze of a crosswind. Honing the profile of the rim has changed that and made them increasingly easy to live with.

Tyre integration was a major factor. Narrow has a smaller frontal area, which is good for frontal drag, but we didn’t properly integrate the tyre into the equation.

“It’s faster in terms of lower aerodynamic drag and has better stability in crosswinds, however not all U-shaped rims perform the same. Rims may look similar to the naked eye, but complex curves on the rims make a huge difference.

No: Chris Hewings, UK sales and marketing manager, Lightweight