Bold action needed from UCI over disc brakes, says Astana boss
Giuseppe Martinelli calls on the UCI to provide leadership over disc brake debate
- (opens in new tab)
- (opens in new tab)
- (opens in new tab)
- Sign up to our newsletter Newsletter

The UCI needs to act strongly over recent disc brake controversies and their use, says Astana team manager Giuseppe Martinelli.
His comment comes a day after Marcel Kittel (Quick Step Floors), who was riding a disc-equipped bike, crashed with Owain Doull (Sky). Doull said that Kittel's rotor cut through his left shoe and foot, and after the peloton's reaction, Kittel decided to switch back to caliper brakes today.
Martinelli tended to Astana's Fabio Aru this morning as the riders prepared to begin stage two from Abu Dhabi's seaside.
"The UCI truly needs to create a date to roll them out, we either go with them or we don't," Martinelli told Cycling Weekly after helping his team's leader.
"We can't go ahead like we've done 1000 times before, with a general opinion that is never made official. Now, it's like whoever has [disc brakes] says that they want to use them, and whoever doesn't puts doubts on their validity.
Martinelli, who won three stages in the Giro d'Italia during his time as a rider in the late 1970s and early 1980s and has directed teams since the 1990s, shook his head. He added, "Like always in cycling, there's much confusion."
Matthew Brammeier (Aqua Blue Sport) wrote something similar on Twitter overnight to the UCI’s Technical Manager Mark Barfield. He said, "Stand up Mark Barfield @UCI_cycling. It's time to be bold."
Watch: What do the pros really think about disc brakes?
Last year, Lampre-Merida and Direct Energie used disc brakes in some races, including Paris-Roubaix. So far in 2017, Shimano and Specialized lead the way through the Quick-Step team.
Tom Boonen (Quick-Step Floors) became the first professional to win on them in the Vuelta a San Juan in January. Kittel rode on a disc-equipped bike to victory in the Dubai Tour shortly afterwards.
"We are not pushing anyone to use them," Specialized team liaison Patrizia Falchero told Cycling Weekly.
"As you can see, [Quick-Step] have rim brakes and disc brakes here. They are free to use what they prefer, depending on the race or anything. We believe in both brake systems, and they choose what they want to [use]. We are not pushy."
Kittel said this morning that he decided to use a caliper bike given the opinions expressed by other riders in the peloton overnight. It appeared to be a setback for the disc brake movement and the manufactures involved.
>>> UCI failed to take into account rider fears about disc brakes, claims CPA
"It's respecting what the peloton wants. It's fair enough, we are not pushing them, so he's free to do what he wants," Falchero added.
"What he thinks is better for the race. Maybe he'll start on disc brakes another day, I don't know. He's free to do that.
"I think we need to analyse and be sure what happens before judging or pointing your finger."
Falchero was also unsure whether a disc brake could have caused the cut to Doull's shoe and foot, saying that more analysis was needed into the incident.
"For us, it's not possible, but I can't say what happened officially. It could've been the barrier, it could've been the disc brake, it could've been anything. Before judging, I think we need to analyse it professionally."
Thank you for reading 10 articles this month* Join now for unlimited access
Enjoy your first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription
Join now for unlimited access
Try first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
Gregor Brown is an experienced cycling journalist, based in Florence, Italy. He has covered races all over the world for over a decade - following the Giro, Tour de France, and every major race since 2006. His love of cycling began with freestyle and BMX, before the 1998 Tour de France led him to a deep appreciation of the road racing season.
-
-
Best commuter bike pedals 2023 - our picks rated and reviewed
From flats to clipless SPDs, we've sorted through the best pedals for your daily commute so you don't have to
By Luke Friend • Published
-
Giro Ethos MIPS helmet review - indicator lights: great or gimmick?
A feature heavy helmet with some novel integrations. The functionality is flawless but whether it's worth the premium price tag is less obvious
By Andy Turner • Published
-
Lava in the metaverse - Five things we want to see from a virtual Track Champions League
The competition is becoming more and more immersive, so here are a few suggestions
By Tom Davidson • Published
-
Tailwind heaven: Moroccan one-day race tops 56km/h average speed
Strong Saharan winds propel riders at Grand Prix Sakia El Hamra
By Tom Davidson • Published
-
Nairo Quintana to leave Arkéa-Samsic, six weeks after signing new contract
The Colombian is currently appealing his Tour de France disqualification
By Tom Davidson • Published
-
Nino Schurter claims astonishing tenth mountain bike world title
The Swiss rider is considered the greatest of all time.
By Tom Davidson • Published
-
It's time we had a serious, adult discussion about cycling's appalling impact on the environment so here are eight achievable proposals
No more pretending that we care; it's time to implement these measures to make an actual difference
By Chris Marshall-Bell • Last updated
-
Italian neo-pro Michele Gazzoli banned for one year for 'non-intentional' anti-doping violation
23-year-old has Astana-Qazaqstan contract terminated as a result of sanction
By Adam Becket • Published
-
Philippe Gilbert slams UCI for ‘negligence’ at Vuelta a Burgos
‘It’s time safety topics are taken seriously’ says Belgian former World Champion
By Tom Thewlis • Published
-
Miguel Ángel López suspended by Astana-Qazaqstan over reported links to doctor under police investigation
Team suspend Colombian rider until circumstances of the Police investigation are clarified
By Tom Thewlis • Published