Once the choice was simple: clincher v tubular. But now tubeless are on the brink of taking off, and in some situations they might be perfect

If you’ve bought a new bike in the past year or so, chances are the wheelset is ‘tubeless-ready’. The technology has been around for several years and the number of manufacturers now making them is reaching a tipping point. Last month Zipp, builder of the most sought-after carbon wheels on the market, announced its first tubeless-ready wheelset.

>>> Buyer’s guide to road bike tyres

In the past, road tyres came in two options: clincher, with an open tyre and separate inner tube; or tubular, with a rubber tread stuck to an enclosed canvas casing, and a tube inside, that you glue to the wheel rim.

Clinchers — or high pressures (HPs) — have always been the first choice for general cycling due to ease of use when you puncture, and cost. Tubulars remain the tyre of choice for track racing, time trialling and much of the pro peloton.

>>> Will carbon clinchers kill off tubular tyres?

For some time now mountain bikers have used tubeless tyres — a system very similar to a car tyre where an open rubber outer tyre sits firmly in a wheel’s rim. No inner tube is needed as the rims and valve are sealed. Air sits in the cavity between the wheel rim and the inside of the tyre.

Off-road there are many benefits as tyres can be run at lower pressure — giving better grip — with no risk of pinch punctures. The benefits might not be so obvious on the road where running tyres at such low pressure doesn’t offer many benefits.

Video – Can a tubeless tyre survive a nail?

Fewer flats, thicker tread

Tubeless tyre systems do, however, suffer from fewer flats than clinchers as they are run with sealant inside that will instantly dry around a hole and seal it. Tubeless tyres can also run a slightly thicker tread without compromising feel, which with only one layer between the wheel and the tarmac is said to be better than clinchers.

>>> Solid tyres go mainstream as Wiggle stocks up

If the system does fail when you’re out on a ride, an inner tube can always be fitted to get you home.

So, with so much going for them, why aren’t tubeless tyres more popular? Cycle tech legend Keith Bontrager is a fan, but understands their limitations: “I came into road tubeless from many years of mountain bike tubeless experience, so there wasn’t really much new that had to be done. The real difference is that the pressure in road bikes tyres is much higher than with mountain bikes, so the sealant behaves a little differently.

>>> Are wider tyres really faster?

“The problem first of all is that the pros don’t use tubeless. They race on tubular for really good reasons — they stay on the rim, they’re light and they roll well. Tubeless tyres are heavy. They’re
probably a little quicker rolling than tubulars in the lightest possible case, but those would also be fragile.

“Another problem with tubeless is that they just take a little more casing to contain air than a tyre with an inner tube,” Bontrager said. “But we fit tubeless-ready wheels to Trek bikes because we anticipated that for sportive riders and for recreational riders the tubeless set-up with sealant would be a popular thing. It’ll take a while, though. The approach to mounting tyres and the maintenance of a tubeless wheel is a little different than with standard inner tubes, and for some people it might be a hassle.”

>>> The best road bike upgrades

Finally, as always with new bike innovation, as different manufacturers come out with their own take on a certain technology, it leads to some confusion. “The international standard is fuzzy, it’s not guaranteed,” Bontrager says. “Having a bunch of proprietary standards that aren’t compatible would be a nightmare. So there is an attempt, and it is a legitimate attempt, to try to make the interface between the tyre and the rim fairly universal.”

Bontrager tubeless ready wheelset

Bontrager Race: tubeless ready wheelset

Our take

Tubeless tyres are nice to ride, and if used with sealant can be quick to fix in the event of a puncture. They won’t take over from clinchers so long as they remain such hard work in the event of total failure.

Because the seating of the tyre bead has to be so secure (to keep the air in) tolerances are tighter, making them extremely hard to get on and off a rim. On a warm summer’s day they would defeat most riders’ grip strength; in the winter they’re as good as impossible to change.

For: Keith Bontrager, bike technology legend

Keith-Bontrager

“I’m a fan, but then I only train on my road bike, I don’t actually race on my road bike, and tubeless tyres are not yet really racing tyres. A tubeless tyre with sealant is much less prone to punctures so, compared to having to change a flat tyre in the rain with buses whizzing past, it’s a much better option. And our Bontrager Tubeless Ready wheels can be used either with or without inner tubes, so you don’t even have to make the call straight away.”

Against: Benjamin Blaurock, Continental Tyres, road tyres product manager

Some parts of the factory are constantly 40 degrees Celsius (Gould)

Continental tyres: no tubeless here. Photo: Daniel Gould

“We don’t make tubeless tyres at Continental right now. The benefit of them in mountain biking is you can use very low pressures for better grip without getting snakebite punctures. But for the traditional road market we don’t think those are as important factors. The construction of road tubeless tyres is a far bigger challenge. You need a heavier system because of the higher pressures, yet weight is a very important factor for road cyclists.”

  • Johnny Laser

    Tubeless for mountain bikes seems to be a con; I don’t know anyone who runs tubeless mtb tires. I’m sure there are some but none of my riding mates run tubeless and we’ve all tried them; they’re heavier than tubes, they’re a pain when they puncture and the whole set-up is time consuming & expensive. When you read the mtb websites and mags you’d think everyone is using tubeless; try it and if it works for you great but they’re not a popular as you’ve been lead to believe.

  • James Gillett

    Heavier training wheels, the tubless types are similiar to training for basketball with weights around your ankles. You can just about fly when you revert to race day wheels / shoes etc.. So put at least a pound or more of slime in the tubeless tyres to train with. 700 gram tyres and 5 lb wheels can become a KOA event. After all there is no special olympics event for bikes yet. Let us get one going.

  • TJ

    you’re right. I had to buy that new bontrager pump that has a compressor thing which helps at home but i understand it’s a faff. At least you know what you get with tubes!

  • Jason Collins

    The bike did not get a puncture. The issue turned out to be that the tires did not want to adhere to the rims 100%. I also learned that you need a very larg compressor to inflate them back up. The unit that works for my car isn’t sufficient to re-inflate tubeless bike tires.

    I ultimately had the shop put a tube in. What a relief. I understand that it takes a certain amount of time & effort to get the tubeless-es to work right. I have a hard enough time fitting in a ride in before dark. I wasn’t ready to wrestle with tires.

  • TJ

    you probably had a bad sort i have to say i was in your camp my first puncture which was too big a hole to fix.

    but my second one was pretty interesting as it just seemed to fix itself and i didn’t have sort changing tyres and just rode home another 10miles without even needing to pump up. if most flats fix like this would be a dream for me as i do sportives and it’s one less hassle

  • TJ

    I’ve had 2 punctures on my tubeless tyres (schwalbe ones) the first time i had to get the tube in as the hole was too big and latex was just spewing everywhere when i tried to cycle on

    On today’s ride i felt the hissing and latex going out then it stopped as the latex presumably plugged the gap

    It then it seemed to start hissing again when i got back on the saddle a couple of times but then stopped as i continued to ride.

    My questions are

    1) what are you actually meant to do when you get a puncture? keep riding and hope for the best? stopped and try and find the hole and put finger over so the sealant sort of stays there??
    2) secondly, if you get home without having to fix the tyre do you need to patch it from the inside or has the latex effectively sorted it permanently??

  • Jason Collins

    Tubeless tires are the worst! The shop that sold me my stumpjumper convinced me to replace the stock tires with tubeless ones. What a scam. Tubeless tires do not retain air. And it’s impossible to re-inflate them once they go flat. Tubeless tires ruined my “new bike experience.” I have photos & video to prove this.