These bibs are certainly warm and we like the styling and the warmth, but they are flawed with regards to fit and comfort. With an RRP of £99.99 we feel this can't be overlooked. This is a shame as Madison have impressed us hugely with other products.
Constrictive above the knee
Not very stretchy material
Chamois uncomfortable for us
Why you can trust Cycling Weekly Our expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing products and services so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about how we test.
There's little debate that a good pair of winter bib tights are essential for riding in cold weather. The main criteria on which we judge a pair of bib tights are: fit, comfort, warmth, breathability, value and bonus features.
The Madison Sportive Shield Softshell bib tights were certainly warm and breathability was also good, but they failed badly in other areas. Our tester was 6'1" and 69kg with a size medium fitting poorly. The height was fine, but there was lots of loose material around the knee and they felt constrictive in other areas.
In an effort to see if we had the wrong size, other members of the Cycling Weekly tech team also tried the bibs, but also experienced sagging around the knee. The material used in these bibs is windproof, but at the cost of not being very elastic. We found that this resulted in a constrictive feel in certain places, including the joint. We felt this restricted movement.
We found the chamois to be uncomfortable too. Whilst derrière comfort is hugely subjective we really didn't get along with this pad. After 20km we found ourselves riding out of the saddle for relief.
The bibs come very high up the torso, which was good for warmth. The zip was useful for regulating temperature but didn't go low enough for aiding 'comfort breaks'. To end on some positives, we do like the styling on the ankle and the stirrups are a good feature too. They are also amongst the warmest bib tights we have worn. The £99.99 RRP puts them in the mid range for bibtights.
For more information, head over to Madison (opens in new tab).
Thank you for reading 10 articles this month* Join now for unlimited access
Enjoy your first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription
Join now for unlimited access
Try first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
Oliver Bridgewood - no, Doctor Oliver Bridgewood - is a PhD Chemist who discovered a love of cycling. He enjoys racing time trials, hill climbs, road races and criteriums. During his time at Cycling Weekly, he worked predominantly within the tech team, also utilising his science background to produce insightful fitness articles, before moving to an entirely video-focused role heading up the Cycling Weekly YouTube channel, where his feature-length documentary 'Project 49' was his crowning glory.
'I'm studying maths – my brain needs something else besides cycling': Thomas Gloag on his hunger for learning on and off the bike
The 21-year-old Londoner and new Jumbo-Visma signing on rising to the challenge as he begins his WorldTour career
By Chris Marshall-Bell • Published
Jess Roberts doubles up at British Track Championships as 19 year-old sprinter topples Olympian
Comeback queen wins her first solo national title in the scratch race
By Vern Pitt • Published
Extinction Rebellion stages anti-Shell protest at British Track Champs
Two people carried a banner through the stands at Newport's Geraint Thomas National Velodrome
By Vern Pitt • Published