Six reasons why mechanical groupsets are better than electronic

If it ain't broke, don't fix it

Sure, there are some reasons to buy an electronic groupset instead of a mechanical groupset, but we've done alright without batteries, wires, and junction boxes for so long that why do we really need to change?

So if you're considering buying a new bike and can't decide between electronic or mechanical shifting, here are six reasons why you should stick with what you know.

1. There are no batteries to recharge

sram red etap battery

Now where did I put that charger?

A couple of months ago I got an old bike out of the back of the garage that was equipped with 20-year-old Campagnolo Veloce, and you know what, with a bit of lube it worked perfectly. If this had been an electronic groupset then the batteries would probably have been flat after only a few months in storage.

>>> Are electronic groupsets necessary?

If you're forgetful/disorganised then this can also be a problem. Yes the charge should last 1,000-2,000km depending on the system and there are little lights to tell you how much charge is left, but frankly you just want to be able to jump on your bike and know that everything's going to work. And you can bet your bottom dollar that the battery is going to go flat in the middle of a race too.

2. You can fix it yourself

Lezyne SV11 multi-tool

This should be enough to fix anything

What's your knowledge like of e-tubes and wireless protocols? In need of a brush up? Then what are you going to do when you're stuck in the middle of nowhere when something happens and you end up stuck in the 53x11?

>>> Seven essentials you need to take on every ride

Well, if you're using a mechanical groupset then whatever has gone wrong will be able to be fixed with the sort of tools you'll find on any decent multi-tool. With electronic groupsets, this might not be the case.

3. No wires to come unplugged

Neat new bracket holds junction box snugly beneath the stem.

Those wires are just asking for trouble

If it's ultimate reliability that you're after, then mechanical cannot be faulted. Peter Sagan was ruled out of contention in the 2015 edition of Paris-Roubaix when one of his Di2 cables became unplugged, and a similar tale of woe befell one of Cycling Weekly's tech writers (who wishes to remain anonymous) who travelled all the way to the super-fast V718 10 mile time trial course in Hull in search of a PB, only to find himself stuck in a massive gear thanks to a loose connection.

With mechanical gearing there's no chance of this happening. The shifting might not be quite as good as it could be if you manage to mess up the cable routing, but then that's your own fault, isn't it.

Watch: Buyer's guide to road bike groupsets

4. It looks better

Shimano Ultegra electric, London Bike Show 2012

My eyes!

The monstrosity that was the first generation Shimano Ultegra Di2 might be a thing of the past, but you still can't say that electronic groupsets look as smart as their mechanical counterparts. as you've usually got to have an ugly box hanging underneath your stem and have limp wires hanging down everywhere.

>>> Top five worst cycling inventions

Compare that to mechanical with the elegant loop of the cable between emerging from the chainstay and joining up with the rear derailleur, and the much more minimalist appearance of both the front and rear derailleurs, and it's no contest.

5. You've got more choice

Shimano Claris is a seven speed groupset

This isn't going to be going electronic any time soon

Want electronic shifting? Well you've got six groupsets from three manufacturers to choose from? Decide to go mechanical? That number more than triples, and that's even before you start getting into hybrid groupsets or move away from the big three.

>>> Buyer's guide to road bike groupsets (video)

There are also choices to suit every budget. You can get road bikes with mechanical groupsets from just £200, but good luck picking up a bike with electronic shifting for less than two grand.

6. It's much cheaper

tejay van garderen bmc timemachine shimano dura ace di2 rear derailleur

Is it really £1,000 better?

But even if you compare the costs of supposedly similar mechanical and electronic groupsets, then mechanical cannot be trumped. If you're looking at RRPs, then Ultegra is about £550 cheaper than Ultegra Di2, and Dura-Ace is almost £1,000 less than Dura-Ace Di2. One thousand pounds!

>>> The best road bike upgrades

Yes the shifting of Dura-Ace Di2 might be that little bit better than plain old Dura-Ace, but £1,000 better? No way.

Thank you for reading 20 articles this month* Join now for unlimited access

Enjoy your first month for just £1 / $1 / €1

*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription

Join now for unlimited access

Try first month for just £1 / $1 / €1