Tour comment: Is Bradley Wiggins the best ever Brit?

Bradley Wiggins may have just done the best ride ever by a British cyclist.

Fourth place in just his third Tour de France is an achievement equal to Chris Hoy’s at the Olympics last year, what Mark Cavendish has done this year, and arguably better than Robert Millar’s fourth in 1984.

It’s impossible to compare Wiggins’ and Millar’s rides like for like, but it is possible to compare them. First let’s look at the time gaps. Millar was 14-42 minutes down on winner Laurent Fignon in ‘84 and was arguably never in contention. All being well tomorrow, Wiggins will finish this year’s Tour just 6-01 minutes down on Alberto Contador, and has been within a few minutes of the race lead throughout the three weeks.

But going on time alone is, I admit, a bit misleading. The Tour was a totally different beast back then as the racing was far less controlled by the strong teams. Large time gaps could open one day only to be overhauled the next.

Millar did win a stage to Guzet Neige in 1984 and win the polka dot jersey competition, which for many could put his ride that year above Wiggins’.

But if you look at Franco Pellizotti’s King of the Mountains win this year you can see how it’s not always such an achievement. Good; yes. Outstanding; not necessarily.

The key is to look at the quality of the respective fields, and I think this is where Wiggins just edges back in front.

True, 1984 had a very strong top five with four of the biggest names of that generation surrounding Millar in the results, but this year was perhaps the strongest grand tour field assembled in years.

Take a look at who Wiggins was up against. First of all Alberto Contador; undoubtedly the greatest stage race rider alive at the moment. The Spaniard has now won two Tours de France, a Giro d’Italia and a Vuelta a Espana. He is as close to unbeatable as it’s possible to get right now.

Then you have Andy Schleck. The Luxembourg champ is a precociously talented climber who is set to win several grand tours himself.

In third place is Lance Armstrong. A seven time winner of the Tour, patron of the peloton in his day, and still one of the most feared/respected riders around. Watching Wiggins go mano-a-mano with him in the mountains was exhilarating.

Below Wiggins is Frank Schleck and Andreas Klöden. Frank may not have the talent of his brother, but to beat him is no mean feat. Then Klöden. What can you say about Klöden? The German has been named in a high-ranking investigation as someone who used the blood-doping services at Freiburg university.

He has so far brushed it off, but the situation is unlikely to go away so easily. Whatever you think of him, Wiggins still had to beat him.

Elsewhere in the field was Carlos Sastre, Denis Menchov, Oscar Pereiro, Cadel Evans, and a host of other riders who have featured and / or won major races in the last two or three years.

We must also put Wiggins’ ride in to context. The Briton has essentially trained for this in just the last nine months; transforming himself from the best track rider in the world to one of the best road riders in the world. It is an incredible achievement.

Millar was always a grand tour rider. That’s what he did, and it’s undeniable that his Tour de France pedigree is greater than Wiggins’, but for Bradley to finish in fourth at his first (proper) attempt, riding against the people he was is simply incredible and makes you wonder what he could do next year.

Tour de France 1984 result
1. L Fignon
2. B Hinault
3. G LeMond
4. Millar
5. Kelly
6. Arroyo
7. P Simon
8. P Munoz
9. C Criquielion
10. P Anderson

Tour de France 2009 – the hub: Index to reports, photos, previews and more.


Stage 20: Contador’s Tour lead safe; Wiggins retains fourth overall on Ventoux

Stage 19: Five star Cavendish wins Tour stage in to Aubenas

Stage 18: Contador tightens grip on the maillot jaune

Stage 17: Schleck brothers overhaul Wiggins as Frank wins the stage

Stage 16: Astarloza snatches Alps stage win as contenders wind up the pace

Stage 15: Contador wins in Verbier as Tour explodes into life

Stage 14: Ivanov wins as Nocentini clings onto yellow

Stage 13: Haussler braves rain for victory in Colmar

Stage 12: Sorensen wins in Vittel as Cavendish goes for green

Stage 11: Cavendish takes fourth win to equal Hoban’s record

Stage 10: Cavendish spoils Bastille Day party to take third stage win

Stage nine: Third French win as contenders content with ceasefire

stage eight: Sanchez wins from break as Tour favourites cancel each other out

Stage seven: Feillu wins at Arcalis, Nocentini takes yellow, Contador leap-frogs Lance

Stage six: Millar’s brave bid denied on Barcelona hill as Hushovd triumphs

Stage five: Voeckler survives chase to win his first Tour stage

Stage four: Astana on top but Armstrong misses yellow by hundredths of a second

Live Tour de France stage four TTT coverage

Stage three: Cavendish wins second stage as Armstrong distances Contador

Stage two: Cavendish takes first sprint

Stage one: Cancellara wins opening time trial

Tour de France 2009 News Index>>
Armstrong admits he suffered in Tour’s final time trial
Wiggins set for Ventoux showdown at the Tour
Radio Shack confirmed as Armstrong’s new backer
Astana to split after Tour
Voigt crashes out of Tour
Armstrong fighting hard for Tour podium place
Wiggins gets closer to Tour podium place
Who’s won what so far in the Tour de France
How the Tour favourite are doing (Rest day 2)
Wiggins climbs to third in Tour overall
Armstrong concedes he can’t win the 2009 Tour
Tom Boonen quits the Tour de France
Stage 15 analysis: Is the Tour now over?
Columbia criticise Garmin for chasing Hincapie
Cavendish reveals he is going for green


Mont Ventoux preview

Garmin-Slipstream’s HQ before the Tour

David Zabriskie’s time trial bike

Mark Cavendish on the Tour’s team time trial

David Brailsford interview

Mark Cavendish on the Tour

Jonathan Vaughters on Bradley Wiggins’ chances



20 photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage 19 photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage 18 photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage 17 photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage 16 photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage 15 photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage 14 photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage 13 photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage 12 photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage 11 photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage 10 photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage nine photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage eight photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage seven photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage six photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage five photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage four TTT photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage three photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage two photo gallery by Graham Watson

Stage one photo gallery by Andy Jones

Stage one photo gallery by Graham Watson

Team presentation by Andy Jones

Team presentation by Graham Watson

Tour de France 2009 – the hub
Tour de France 2009: Who’s riding
Tour de France 2009: Team guide
About the Tour de France

Tour de France 2009: Who will win?
Tour de France 2009 on TV: Eurosport and ITV4 schedules
Big names missing from 2009 Tour de France
Tour de France anti-doping measures explained
Brits in the Tours: From Robinson to Cavendish
Cycling Weekly’s rider profiles


Follow the Tour on Cycling Weekly’s Twitter feed