'You’ll only ever try to walk on a wet, tiled Café floor carrying coffee in Speedplays once to swear to never do so again' - why Shimano and Look are our preferred pedals
In a contest of best road pedals, these are the clear winners
"CW asks" is a feature series where our seasoned staff answers a range of questions. The series isn't just about delivering knowledge; it's a chance for us to share a bit of our personality and our passion with you. As we dive into some questions, please feel free to send in some questions of your own to anne.rook@futurenet.com.
Question 20: Road pedals: Shimano, Look, Speedplay - which do you use and why?
Stefan Abram, Tech Features Editor
Shimano was always my go-to. I really liked how easy it was to service the pedals, the reliability was great in between times, and it was easy to find them on a good offer. Some people don’t like the size of the cleat, others are evangelists for the ‘stability’ but I don’t really have a strong feeling either way on that front.
But as most power meter pedals all used the Look cleat system (Garmin, Favero, PowerTap), I ended up making the switch for practicality reasons. I do think that Look’s ‘Memory Eyelet’ is a very neat feature, but disappointingly I’ve not actually had the necessary fitting on any of my own shoes!
Hannah Bussey, Technical Writer
Look Keo’s all the way. Back in the early 2000’s Shimano seemed to have got stuck in the past with its chunky and wide platform, especially when you have size 39 feet. Look seemed more progressive in its narrow cleat design, which was still comfortable and stable, so it just kind of stuck with me.
A lot of people raved about Speedplay about 12 or so years ago, hailing them as the saviour of cyclists knees. However, as a Tech Writer, who is perpetually changing shoes, I have neither time or patience to set a pair up Speedplate cleats correctly or be bothered to oil on a regular bases. You’ll only ever try to walk on a wet, tiled Café floor carrying coffee and cake in Speedplays once to swear to never do so again.
Anna Abram, Fitness Features Editor
For road cycling, I now only use Look! I started out with Shimano, but I made the swap to Look a few years ago simply because I wanted to invest in Garmin’s Vector 3 power meter pedals (which was only available as a Look-style pedal and pairs with Look’s cleats).
Swapping pedals is more faff than I want to do on a weekly basis, so I switched to Look Keo pedals for my winter bike to make it easy hopping between the two. A bit of an investment but certainly worth it for simplicity!
Get The Leadout Newsletter
The latest race content, interviews, features, reviews and expert buying guides, direct to your inbox!
The latest iteration of Garmin’s power meter pedals, the Rallys, can now of course be purchased with a Shimano SPD-SL body and so if this was the case back then I might not have moved away from Shimano myself. But now I’m too invested in Look - the pedals are lasting well, so I don’t see myself needing new ones anytime soon and therefore I’ll be sticking with Look now.
Tom Davidson - News and Features Writer
The pedals I have on my bike are my biggest embarrassment. I run a set of Shimano SPD-SL road pedals that I probably bought five years ago. The pedals themselves are fine, and I got them because my brother had a similar set and vouched for them. In the time I’ve had them, however, I’ve bashed them to pieces.
In my hometown, there’s a concrete outdoor velodrome on which I once slid down the banking, ripping the black paint off my pedal and the skin off my knee. The skin healed, but the shredded pedals have gotten worse with each wall I’ve leant them on, and now, the sun beams off their scratched, silvery surface. Still, as people always say, if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it, and they continue to work just fine. I’ll probably upgrade to another Shimano set when the time comes.
Joe Baker - Tech Writer
Without a shadow of a doubt, my top choice will always be Shimano pedals - and for good reason. Over the last few years, I have used Shimano and Look pedals. I've ridden thousands of kilometers on both and put simply, Shimano pedals just last longer (in my experience at least).
While both Look and Shimano offer great retention systems, I have never managed to get more than one year out of Look pedals, thanks I'm sure, in no small part to the grueling British winters!
I like these pedals so much, you can read my love letter to the Shimano pedals, here.
Previous questions:
- What three things do you wish you'd known when you first started cycling?
- Does e-bike racing have a place at the most competitive end of our sport?
- If you were given $3,000 right now, which bike would you buy?
- Personality test: If you could keep just one of your bikes, which bike would it be?
- Ride of a lifetime: If you had just one ride left in you where would it be and with whom?
- Who is the greatest cyclist of all time?
- Ride indoors or brave the elements outdoors: how will you tackle the winter season?
- The great sock debate: do socks go over or under leg warmers?
- Tubeless vs. tubed tires on the road?
- SRAM, Shimano or Campagnolo? Here's what our staff prefers and why
- What's the 'right' tire width for road and gravel riding?
- What cycling-related items are on our experts' Christmas wish lists?
- Carbon rim brakes, bar ends and straightforward headsets: cycling tech of old we miss
- What are the silliest UCI rules that should be done away with?
- Five bike parts to invest in, and five things to cheap out on
- What's the sweet spot to spend on a bike?
- What are some bike hacks you continue to use?
- Bike bells: a useful tool or dispensable noise makers?
- What has been the best invention in modern cycling?
Got questions —silly or serious— you'd like for us to tackle? Please send your questions to anne.rook@futurenet.com.
Thank you for reading 20 articles this month* Join now for unlimited access
Enjoy your first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription
Join now for unlimited access
Try first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
Cycling Weekly's North American Editor, Anne-Marije Rook is old school. She holds a degree in journalism and started out as a newspaper reporter — in print! She can even be seen bringing a pen and notepad to the press conference.
Originally from The Netherlands, she grew up a bike commuter and didn't find bike racing until her early twenties when living in Seattle, Washington. Strengthened by the many miles spent darting around Seattle's hilly streets on a steel single speed, Rook's progression in the sport was a quick one. As she competed at the elite level, her journalism career followed, and soon she became a full-time cycling journalist. She's now been a cycling journalist for 11 years.
-
Forget distance covered, these are the key stats to note in your Strava Year in Sport
We asked a coach how to best analyse our end of year Strava data
By Tom Davidson Published
-
'She should show a bit more respect' - Lotte Kopecky responds to Demi Vollering comments
The pair seemingly had one last fractious year together at SD Worx-Protime in 2024
By Tom Davidson Published
-
GPS computers, smart trainers and electronic shifting - these are the best modern cycling innovations, our experts say
What has been the best invention in modern cycling?
By Anne-Marije Rook Published
-
Bike bells: a useful tool or dispensable noise makers?
At what price point do you get a capable, fun bike which most riders can be happy with? It's been $2 and $4K our experts say
By Anne-Marije Rook Published
-
Frozen water bottles, dollar bills, 3D printed solutions and full-sized Allen keys — our staff's favorite bike 'hacks'
Our experts share there bike hacks, from fashioning a tire boot from a dollar bill or ensuring you have a cool bottle in summer.
By Anne-Marije Rook Published
-
Five bike parts to invest in, and five things to cheap out on
Our experts advice on where to save your pennies and where to pay full price
By Anne-Marije Rook Published
-
6.8kg bikes, unauthorized feeds, puppy paws — here are the silliest UCI rules that should be done away with
The UCI sets some hard rules to keep the sport safe and fair but some rules are just silly.
By Anne-Marije Rook Published
-
Books, heated gloves, steel bottles and a cycling vacation - what our staff is asking for this Christmas
Opinion is divided among cyclists as to whether to wear your socks over or under your leg warmers. Here's what our staff thinks
By Anne-Marije Rook Published
-
SRAM, Shimano or Campagnolo? Here's what our staff prefers and why
Opinion is divided among cyclists as to whether to wear your socks over or under your leg warmers. Here's what our staff thinks
By Anne-Marije Rook Published